When I was in my early twenties, Ben coerced me into trying out for a few plays with him. I did, but only to discover that I hated acting. He got Ruth and me try out for A Christmas Carol one year. Having the unusual talent of convincing people we were from foreign countries by perfecting the accent, we were all given parts. It was sort of a play within a play, so we were given several roles each. Ruth got all the young lady parts, I got all the older lady ones and Ben got the part of Jacob Marley and a few others.
The director, a woman who although very well intended, lacked theatrical common sense. For instance, she cast the fattest boy I ever saw as Tiny Tim! Not only fat, but ill mannered, loud, disobedient and unbearable in every way. She also cast his slightly less rotund sister for the young girl parts.
One of my roles was that of Mrs. Cratchet. If you’re at all familiar with the book, you will recall the scene where Mrs. Cratchet is lamenting the loss of her sweet, deceased boy and says the line “With Tiny Tim on his shoulder, your father would walk very fast indeed. But he was light to carry and your father loved him so that it was no trouble”. The fool I felt at having to deliver that line made my throat swell and my eyes water.
A patron of the theater after a performance, commended me on my realistic portrayal of a grieving mother and said that she sensed my “genuine affection” for him. “Him?” I said puzzled, “Oh you mean Tiny Tim! Ah yes… he’s… so like the character he plays.” It occurred to me that the only thing that would make that repulsive boy even remotely like Tiny Tim, would be to cripple him. And the thought crossed my mind a hundred times a day.
During the dress rehearsal, Portly Tim (as we called him) was slapping his sister through one of our prop windows while we were receiving direction. Ben got up from his seat and went over to the window, put his forearm around Tim’s neck and squeezed it firmly, then whispered in his ear “You’re not serious about acting, so I’m going to give you this one chance to shape up, or my sister and I are going to take you up into the mountains, and no one will ever hear from you again.“ Naturally, Portly Tim told his portly mother, and Ben had to make a portly apology or be faced with a portly lawsuit.
During the run of this play, I got terribly sick, which made my already negative attitude toward it horrendous. The rest of the cast members, excluding my family, complained that my behavior was bringing the whole company down. I stopped ironing my costume, fixing my hair, or delivering my lines with any sincerity at all. I whined that the front stage was too hot and the back stage was too cold. I told the children that there was no Santa Claus and made it clear in every way that I was completely uninterested in how the play went or if my performance in it was any good.
To make things worse, Ruth and I were forced to sing a duet together. I have a very poor voice and Ruth’s is even worse than mine. But the director assured us that is was of little importance and that all we needed to do to make up for it was sing as loud as we could! At one point we were to sing a high E, which I would sing alone as Ruth couldn’t come anywhere close to it. After it was sung, she would rejoin me for the rest of the song.
During my infection, I lost my voice and squeaked out my lines as best I could, but afterwards, Winnie said that I sounded more like a mouse that was being stepped on, over and over again. When the fated high E came onto the scene, it was met by complete silence! Both our mouths were open, but not a sound escaped! I looked at Ruth, who gave me a piteous, wide eyed look, like I had just sold her to the gypsies. The silence endured until we both fell off the platform we were standing on from laughing. It was laughter, but given my voiceless condition it looked more like I was going into cardiac arrest.
We tried our best to incorporate the fiasco into the play, but it was obvious to the audience that something was amiss.
That was the last play I ever did. Ben continued pursuing a career in acting, while I was permitted to attend some of his performances only with the understanding that I never, ever talk to any of the actors.